Precisely how Old is Acupuncture? Challenging the Neolithic Origins Theory

· 15 min read
Precisely how Old is Acupuncture? Challenging the Neolithic Origins Theory

Although americans often think associated with this traditional Oriental treatment modality because a "new" kind of alternative medicine, acupuncture treatment is indeed ancient in China that their origins are not clear. In accordance with Huangfu Mi (c. 215-282 AD), author of The particular Systematic Classic of Acupuncture and Moxibustion, needling therapy has been first used throughout China's Bronze Age group, over five thousands of years ago. He features its invention to be able to either Fu Xi or Huang Dalam (the Yellow Emperor), two legendary numbers of the Five Emperors Period (c. 3000-2070 BC). Modern historians generally believe that will acupuncture is much more mature, originating over ten thousand yrs ago during China's Neolithic Age (c. 8000-3500 BC).

In actuality, acupuncture may not get as ancient since has generally already been assumed. A reconsideration of all extant documents and current archaeological finds shows that acupuncture might go as far back a simple 2100 to 2300 years, first showing during China's Warring States Period (475-221 BC) and quickly maturing in the Traditional western Han Dynasty (206 BC-24 AD).

Questioning the generally recognized origins theory.

The currently accepted concept concerning the Neolithic origins of acupuncture therapy is founded on two property. The very first holds that bian shi, specific sharp-edged stone resources that appeared in the course of China's Neolithic Age group, were used intended for an early type of needling therapy, prior to the invention of material smelting. It is known that bian shi stone resources were utilized regarding a number involving early medical processes, starting during the Neolithic Age and moving forward through the European Han Dynasty (206 BC-24 AD). A number of descriptions of bian shi stone treatment appear in one particular of China's first medical works, The particular Yellow Emperor's Inner Classic of Medicine (Huang Di Neijing, hereafter referred to as the Neijing) (c. 104-32 BC). That has been thought that all these Neolithic rock medical instruments were precursors of typically the metal acupuncture small needles that came into work with during China's Flat iron Age.

However, famous documents and brand-new archaeological evidence plainly indicate that bian shi stone tools were flat plus knife-like in form, used primarily in order to incise abscesses in order to discharge pus, or to draw blood (1). They have been applied as operative scalpels to cut, quite than as needles to puncture, and had nothing to carry out with needling treatment. Based on the Code regarding Hammurabi, the ancient inhabitants of Mesopotamia used similarly formed bronze knives to incise abscesses more than 4000 years before.

Prehistoric Chinese folks possessed needles produced of various materials, ranging from primitive thorns and quills to bone, bamboo, pottery, and natural stone. While the background of the cutlery is not the particular history of surgical treatment, so the innovation of needles which of acupuncture will be two entirely different things. Needles have historically been among the most widely used tools of day to day life with regard to constructing garments all over the planet. Medically, needles are used to stitch incisions just while making up garments with darners, hollowed out syringe needles (as differentiated from a solid needle utilized in acupuncture) happen to be applied to inject fluids into the particular body or draw them from that, but pricking a new solid needle into the body to take care of illness seems very strange and enigmatical. In English, "to give somebody the particular needle" means to be able to displease or irritate someone. Most people like not to end up being punctured with sharp needles, and associate needling with pain and even injury. Many crops and animals include evolved thorns or perhaps quills as strong weapons for protection or attack. Needles were even utilized for punishment throughout ancient China. By simply trial and mistake, healers throughout typically the world have identified treatments for pain as well as other diseases independently, for instances, herbal products, roots, wraps, rubs, blood-letting and surgical procedure, but acupuncture alone is exclusive to China. Thinking about the unique Far east origin of acupuncture therapy, it is reasonable to be able to assume that the innovation of acupuncture has been not related to be able to the availability of possibly sewing needles or bian shi natural stone scalpels during China's Neolithic Age.

The particular second premise helping the theory with the Neolithic origins associated with acupuncture holds of which acupuncture evolved like a natural outgrowth of daily life throughout prehistoric times. That is thought that all via a process involving fortuitous accident and repeated empirical encounter, it had been discovered that needling various points on the body could effectively treat various conditions. On the other hand, this assumption is usually with a lack of both basic historical evidence in addition to a logical groundwork.

It is recognized that ancient individuals were aware of circumstances in which physical troubles were relieved following unrelated injury. Many of these a case had been reported by Zhang Zihe (c. 1156-1228 AD), one associated with the four prestigious physicians in the Jin and Yuan Lignage (1115-1368 AD) and a specialist in blood-letting therapy: "Bachelor Zhao Zhongwen produced an acute eyesight problem during their participation in typically the imperial examination. His eyes became reddish colored and swollen, accompanied by blurred eye-sight and severe pain. The pain seemed to be so unbearable that he contemplated death. One day, Zhao was inside teahouse with the friend. Suddenly, the stovepipe fell in addition to hit him about the forehead, triggering a wound concerning 3-4 cun long and letting copious amounts of darkish purple blood. When the bleeding ended, a miracle experienced occurred. Zhao's eye stopped hurting; can see the road and was capable to go residence on his own. The following day he can make out the shape of his roofing. Within several days, having been completely retrieved. The case was cured without having intentional treatment yet only accidental shock (2). "

If acupuncture did, in fact , gradually develop as being the result of like fortuitous accidents, China's four thousand yrs of recorded background should include several similar accounts with regards to the discovery of the acupoints and their particular properties. But my extensive search involving the immense Oriental medical canon as well as other literature has yielded only this individual case. Actually, this kind of story offers at most an example regarding blood-letting therapy, which differs in a few fundamental regards from acupuncture treatment. The point regarding blood-letting therapy is definitely to eliminate a specific amount of blood vessels. When puncturing the body with solid needles, absolutely nothing is extra to or subtracted from the entire body.

Blood-letting therapy is usually universal. Throughout documented history, people around the world include had similar activities with the success of accidental personal injury, and have designed healing methods based on the principle that injuring and even inducing bleeding in a part of the particular body can relieve problems within area. The ancient Greeks and Romans developed venesection and cupping based on the discovery that blood loss is helpful in cases such as a fever, headache, and disordered menstruation. Europeans in the Middle Ages employed blood-letting as a panacea for your elimination and remedying of condition. Detailed directions have been given concerning the particular best days and hours for blood-letting, the right veins to be tapped, the particular amount of blood vessels that must be taken, and typically the number of bleedings. Blood was generally taken by starting a vein together with a lancet, but sometimes by blood-sucking leeches or along with the use involving cupping vessels. Blood-letting using leeches is definitely still practiced in certain areas of The european union plus the Middle East. However , nowhere do these blood-letting methods develop into a detailed plus comprehensive system comparable to regarding acupuncture treatment. If acupuncture did indeed arise by repeated empirical expertise of accidental damage, it should have developed around the globe, rather than just in China.

Both historical evidence and reason indicate that generally there is no reason relation between typically the development of materials and even processes for making sharp needles along with the invention regarding acupuncture. It is definitely also clear that repeated experience regarding fortuitous accidental personal injury was not a primary factor in the development of acupuncture. Therefore, the generally accepted theory with regards to the Neolithic origins regarding acupuncture, based since it is upon such flawed premises, must be incorrect. It is definitely now necessary in order to reconsider when acupuncture therapy did, in fact, first appear and subsequently mature.

Reconsidering the evidence

In case acupuncture did certainly originate during China's Neolithic Age, recommendations to it need to appear throughout China's earliest written records and archaeological artifacts. Yet , this is not the case.

Early cultures thought the world to end up being filled with the supernatural, and designed various methods associated with divination. During China's Shang Dynasty (c. 1500-1000 BC), divination was practiced simply by burning animal bones and tortoise covers with moxa or perhaps many other materials. Oracular pronouncements were then inscribed for the bone or shell, based upon the resulting crackles. These inscriptions have got survived as typically the earliest examples involving written Chinese characters. Among the thousands of inscribed oracle bones and shells found to day, 323 contain forecasts concerning over 20 different diseases and even disorders. However, nothing of these épigraphe mention acupuncture, or even any other kind of treatment for that will matter.

Rites of the Zhou Dynasty (Zhou Li), composed during the Warring States Period (475-221 BC), records inside detail the official rituals and regulations of the Zhou Empire (c. 1000-256 BC), including those concerning medicine. Royal physicians at that time were broken into a number of categories: dieticians, who else were responsible with regard to the rulers' foods and drink; doctors of internal remedy, who treated disorders and disorders using grains and natural herbs; surgeons, or yg yi, who treated problems such since abscesses, open sores, wounds, and fractures using zhuyou (incantation), medication , and debridement (using stone or even metal knives to scrape and get rid of pus and necrotic tissue); and vets, who treated pets. But this file at the same time contains not any references to acupuncture.



Neijing (c. 104-32 BC) will be the primary known work with regards to acupuncture. Typical is made up of two pieces: Suwen - Basic Questions, and Lingshu - the Faith based Pivot, also acknowledged as The Classic involving Acupuncture (Zhen Jing). Both are concerned primarily with typically the theory and exercise of acupuncture and even moxibustion. Although authorship with the Neijing is usually related to Huang Dalam, the legendary Yellow-colored Emperor (c. 2650 BC), most students consider that this specific master work, which usually contains excerpts by more than twenty pre-existing medical treatises, was actually gathered between 104 BC and 32 BC, throughout the latter part of the Western Han dynasty (206 BC-24 AD). The comprehensive and extremely developed nature involving the medical technique presented in the Neijing has brought scholars to trust of which needling therapy features an extremely prolonged history, probably getting back to prehistoric times. The initial versions of the old texts utilized in the particular compilation of the Neijing have been dropped, and with all of them the opportunity to further illumine the question of any time acupuncture actually 1st appeared. Yet , surprising new archaeological data, unearthed in Tiongkok in the early on 1970s and 1980s, reveals the right state of Chinese medicine before the Neijing, and challenges existing assumptions regarding the Neolithic origins of acupuncture treatment.

In late 1973, fourteen medical files, known as the particular Ancient Medical Artefacts of Mawangdui, had been excavated from Burial plot No. 3 from Mawangdui, Changsha, Hunan Province. Ten involving the documents had been hand-copied on silk, and four had been written on bamboo bedding slips. The precise age of the Ancient Medical Artifacts of Mawangdui is not determined. However, a wooden tablet found in the grave says that the deceased was your son of Prime Minister Li Chang of typically the state of Changsha, and that they were buried in February 24, 168 BC.  https://medical.com  and empirical characteristics of the material comprised in the records indicates that these people were written properly before their interment in 168 BC, probably throughout the midsection of the Warring States Period (475-221 BC). In any kind of event, it will be sure that these healthcare documents pre-date the Neijing (compiled d. 104-32 BC), making them the most ancient known medical files in existence. These types of documents were possibly lost sometime during the Eastern Han Empire (25-220 AD), considering that no mention associated with them has recently been found from this period until their rediscovery in 1973.

One other valuable medical find, The Book associated with the Meridians (Mai Shu), was excavated from two ancient tombs at Zhangjiashan in Jiangling Local, Hubei Province found in 1983. These ancient texts, written on the subject of bamboo slips and even quite well conserved, were probably smothered between 187 plus 179 BC, all-around the same time since the Mawangdui relics. There are 5 documents in most, three of which (The Classic of Moxibustion with Eleven Yin-Yang Meridians, Methods of Heart beat Examination and Bian Stone, and Indications of Death in the Yin-Yang Meridians) are identical towards the texts found in Mawangdui.

There will be abundant evidence in order to show that the authors of the particular Neijing used the previously medical texts by Mawangdui and Zhangjiashan as primary referrals, further indicating the antiquity of these relics. For example, Part 10 of typically the Lingshu section associated with the Neijing consists of a discussion regarding the meridians and their disorders that is very comparable, in the form plus content, to of which found in vintage of Moxibustion using Eleven Yin-Yang Meridians, one of the particular documents available at both Mawangdui and Zhangjiashan.

Of course, the Neijing did not necessarily simply reproduce these kinds of earlier documents, but rather refined in addition to developed them, in addition to introduced new treatment methods. The sooner Classic of Moxibustion with Eleven Yin-Yang Meridians is limited to moxibustion, while Section 10 of the particular Lingshu section involving the Neijing says needling therapy, or even acupuncture, the first time. Despite the fact that the medical texts preceding the Neijing discuss a broad variety of curing techniques, including herbal medicine, moxibustion, fomentation, medicinal bathing, bian stone therapy, massage, daoyin (physical exercises), xingqi (breathing exercises), zhuyou (incantation), as well as surgery, these previous documents contain zero mention of acupuncture treatment.

If needling remedy did indeed form much earlier as compared to the Neijing (c. 104-32 BC), typically the medical documents unearthed from Mawangdui and Zhangjiashan, very possibly used as major references by Neijing's authors, also need to include extensive discussions involving acupuncture. Yet , they do not. This particular clearly indicates that acupuncture was certainly not yet utilized with the time of which the Mawangdui in addition to Zhangjiashan documents have been compiled. Of course , this is not probable to draw a new detailed picture associated with the state regarding acupuncture early within the Western Han Dynasty (206 BC-24 AD) based solely for the medical relics from Mawangdui and Zhangjiashan. But the simple fact that these documents were considered valuable enough to become buried with the departed indicates that that they do reflect basic medical practice from the time.

Typically the Historical Records (Shi Ji) (c. 104-91 BC) by Talud Qian contains facts that acupuncture was first used approximately one hundred years prior to the compilation of the Neijing (c. 104-32 BC). Typically the Historical Records, China's first comprehensive history, consists of a series of biographies reaching from typically the moments of the popular Yellow Emperor (c. 2650 BC) to Emperor Wudi (156-87 BC) of the Western Han Dynasty. Among they are biographies of China's 2 earliest doctors, Bian Que and Cang Gong. Bian Que's given name was Qin Yueren. This is known that he lived from 407-310 BC, during typically the late Warring Declares Period (475-221 BC), and was some sort of contemporary of Hippocrates (c. 460-377 BC), the father associated with Western medicine. Bian Que's life was surrounded by the aura of secret rendering it difficult to be able to separate fact coming from legend. Call him by his name implies Wayfaring Magpie : a bird which in turn symbolizes good fortune. That is said that will an old guy offered Bian Que the number of esoteric medical texts and an herbal prescription, and even then disappeared. Bian Que took the medicine according in order to the mysterious visitor's instructions. Thirty days later on, he could see through walls. Thereafter, whenever he diagnosed condition, he could plainly view the internal internal organs of his patients' bodies. Just like the centaur Chiron, son associated with Apollo, who is sometimes regarded as the particular god of medical procedures in the To the west, Bian Que will be considered to get a supernatural determine, and the our god of healing. A stone relief, unearthed from a tomb dating back to the Han Dynasty (206 BC-220 AD), describes him having an individual head on a new bird's body (3). The Historical Documents states that Bian Que successfully resuscitated the prince from the State of Guo using a blend of acupuncture, excitation, and herbal medication. Bian Que is usually thus regarded as the founder of acupuncture, and to make the first noted use of acupuncture throughout the Warring Says Period (475-221 BC).

More solid proof connects the birth of acupuncture with all the famous ancient physician Chunyu Yi (c. 215-140 BC), typically known as Cang Gong. Cang Gong's life and job are described throughout detail inside the Historic Records. The Traditional Records claim that in 180 BC, Cang Gong's teacher provided him a variety of precious medical texts that had escaped the particular book-burnings of the previous days of the truly great Qin Empire (221-207 BC). At that will time, adherents regarding all opposing schools of thought were executed or expatriate, and almost almost all books not contouring to the inflexible Legalist doctrines that will dominated the Qin Dynasty were burnt. Although medical text messaging escaped the tragedy, their owners still anticipated persecution. The suspended books that Cang Gong received may have included the number whose titles appear in the particular Ancient Medical Artefacts of Mawangdui, this sort of as the Vintage of Moxibustion with Eleven Yin-Yang Meridians, Classic of Moxibustion with Eleven Foot-Arm Meridians, Method of Pulse Examination plus Bian Stone, Treatment Methods for 52 Disorders, Miscellaneous Forbidden Methods, along with the Book regarding Sex.

Cang Gong's biography in the particular Historical Records examines twenty-five of the cases, dating by approximately 186 BC to 154 BC. These cases research, the earliest inside recorded Chinese record, give an obvious picture of exactly how disease was taken care of over 2100 decades ago. Of typically the twenty-five cases, 10 were diagnosed since incurable and the particular patients died as predicted. From the 20 that were healed, eleven were treated with herbal medicine, 2 with moxibustion in combination with herbal medicine, 1 with needling, and something with needling in combination with pouring cold normal water on the patient's head. It may be seen out of this material that Cang Gong used natural medicine as his primary treatment, and acupuncture and moxibustion only secondarily. Their use of moxibustion adheres strictly to the doctrines noted in the inside relics from Mawangdui and Zhangjiashan. Though only two associated with Cang Gong's moxibustion cases are documented inside the Historical Files, it truly is known that he was skilled in its use, and that this individual wrote a book referred to as Cang Gong's Moxibustion. Unfortunately, this book provides been lost. Compared to his wide-ranging utilization of herbal medicine and moxibustion, Cang Gong applied needling remedy very sparingly. Neither of Cang Gong's two recorded acupuncture therapy cases mentions specific acupoints or how the needles were altered, indicating that needling therapy at the time was continue to in the initial level.

Although acupuncture has been not in common make use of during Cang Gong's day, his two recorded acupuncture people were cured together with only one treatment, indicating the efficiency of the nascent therapy. The fast progress acupuncture was initially soon to follow. By the period the Neijing seemed to be compiled (c. 104-32 BC), approximately a single hundred years after the time regarding Cang Gong, acupuncture had supplanted herbal treatments and moxibustion since the take care of choice. Only thirteen herbal prescriptions are recorded in the Neijing, compared with hundreds utilizing acupuncture.

Archaeological excavations of Traditional western Han Dynasty (206 BC-24 AD) tombs have yielded some sort of number of significant medical relics related to acupuncture, in improvement to the Neijing and Historical Documents. In July regarding 1968, nine steel needles were excavated at Mancheng, Hebei Province from the tomb of Knight in shining armor Liu Sheng (? -113 BC) involving Zhongshan, elder brother of Emperor Wu Di (156-87 BC) with the Western Damien Dynasty (206 BC-24 AD). Four involving the needles are gold and really well preserved, although five are metallic and decayed to the extent that it was not possible to restore them entirely. The number and shapes of the excavated needles indicate of which they could have been a great exhibit from the 9 types of acupuncture treatment needles described within the Neijing. This probability is supported by simply the point that a range of additional healthcare instruments were found in the tomb. These included a bronze yigong (practitioner's basin) used for decocting medicinal herbs or making pills, the bronze sieve utilized to filter herbal decoctions, and a silver precious metal utensil utilized to put medicine (4). Even though many prehistoric bone needles have recently been unearthed, the simple fact that they have eyes indicates of which they were used for sewing. Several scholars have deduced that prehistoric Oriental people may have got used bone small needles found with little eyes or using points on both stops for medical reasons. However, I think that it is break outs to draw this kind of a conclusion established solely on relics that have yang lain buried for countless numbers of years. Rather, it is likely that the sight of these sharp needles have simply corroded on the millennia.

Summary

An intensive reevaluation regarding all extant literary works, as well while documents and archaeological relics unearthed given that the 1960s, concurs with that acupuncture will be not as old as has normally been assumed, and this it did certainly not, in fact , appear in addition to gradually develop during China's Neolithic Era (c. 8000-3500 BC). Rather, this great invention arose very suddenly and rapidly developed approximately 2 millennia ago. Most evidence indicates that acupuncture first made an appearance during the Warring States Period (475-221 BC), during the particular time of Bian Que, developed throughout the early European Han Dynasty (206 BC-24 AD), in the course of the time involving Cang Gong, and had fully grown up by the second option part of typically the Western Han Dynasty, in the time the collection from the Neijing (c. 104-32 BC).

Typically the Western Han Empire (206 BC-24 AD) provided fertile floor to the rapid development and maturation associated with acupuncture as the comprehensive medical method. The previous hundreds of years had seen the blossoming of Oriental culture during the intellectual give-and-take of the Spring plus Autumn (770-476 BC) and Warring Says (475-221 BC) periods. The subsequent comarcal unification of The far east by the Qin Dynasty (221-207 BC) laid a base for that cultural the use in the diverse says. Consumed in the framework of China's a number of thousand years of recorded history, the particular Western Han Empire was a period of intensive social and ethnic advancement. Acupuncture is usually unique. Its technology of acupuncture within China at this particular time was your outcome of the advancement and unique concurrence of several aspects of Chinese lifestyle during this time, including natural scientific research, social structure in addition to human relations, and even most importantly, all natural philosophy.